Asphalt Shingles vs Metal Roof: Which Is Right for You?

 

Projections show that the global roofing market will reach a value of $156 billion by 2030.

You have various choices when it comes to types of roofing, but there are two which are by far the most popular. This guide compares asphalt shingles vs metal roof to help you make a choice about which is best for you.

To find out more, keep reading.

Asphalt Shingles vs Metal Roof

Most roofs today are asphalt shingles. Of these, there are 3 different types:

• 3 tab – named for the three tabs on each shingle strip
• Dimensional – these have a more random pattern resembling the appearance of a wood shake roof
• Luxury/premium – larger than the other styles and more closely resembling a slate roof

They all function similarly, so the choice between the three comes down to your personal preference of how they look.

Metal roofing is the next most common type and can be either standing-seam or screw-down panels. Unlike the types of asphalt, these two have different functional properties.

Standing seam systems have panels that are seamed mechanically. They’re designed to have space to expand and contract with temperature changes.

The screw-down panel, as you may expect, is screwed down, which results in it having no room to expand or contract. If the roof will be over a heated space, or will otherwise be exposed to high temperatures, it’s best to go for a standing seam system.

Check out this guide from Mid-State Construction and Roofing for details of the roofing types they offer.

Lifespan

A properly installed asphalt shingle roof should last for up to 30 years before it needs to be replaced. This can be lower if it’s not properly maintained or if it’s damaged by something such as bad weather.

A metal roof can have a lifespan of up to 50 years. As it’s more durable, it’s more likely to reach its full life expectancy.

Maintenance

If you have an asphalt roof, you should be inspecting it at least once a year and carrying out any necessary maintenance. A standing seam metal roof, on the other hand, experiences far less wear and tear.

Metal roofs will generally last for decades without the need for any maintenance.

Budget

Asphalt shingle roofing is generally cheaper to install than metal roofing. Sometimes a metal roof can cost more than twice as much. Despite this, a metal roof could still be a worthwhile investment.

A metal roof has a longer lifespan, and with the little amount of maintenance required, it can provide you with savings in the long run. A metal roof may also increase the value of your home more, so that may be a factor if you think you might decide to move in the future.

Weather Conditions

When deciding which type is the best roof for you, think about the weather in your local area. If you experience a lot of storms, it could create regular issues for an asphalt shingle roof.

Metal roofing stands up to bad weather, moisture, and other conditions far better, so you may benefit more from choosing a metal roof.

Making Your Choice

When comparing asphalt shingles vs a metal roof, there is no ‘better’ option. The right choice for you comes down to your specific needs. Look at your budget, the weather in your area, and the maintenance you intend to carry out.

All of these will help you decide which roofing style is best for you.

If you’re interested in more home improvement articles, check out some of our other blog posts.